It’s About People Not Policies
We don’t just sell you a policy. Insurance, like people, comes in different shapes and sizes and we are here to help you personalize your insurance needs.
Contact Us Today
Following a tradition of excellence. Leading with experience.
100 years of history—and 1000s of satisfied clients to show for it. Since1919, when Fred H. Otterstedt founded the company, we’ve had a special tie to the families, individuals, and businesses we serve. In 1955 Joe Parisi Sr. purchased the agency from Mr. Otterstedt and, together with his wife Lucille and son Joe Parisi Jr., built one of the tri-state area’s leading insurance agencies, while maintaining the personal focus we began with. Our current President, Bob Casazza, continues to build on this tradition.
Founded In
1919
Client Testimonials:
Thank you so much Kassandra! I used to absolutely dread figuring out my insurance during renewal. Not only is she very knowledgeable, and explains everything to you, she’s very nice! And she was able to help me save money. Highly recommend, you won’t regret it.
I recently switched insurance companies from Allstate to Ottererstedt after being with Allstate for over 20+ years. I worked with Pete Laudenbauk and not only did he save me a lot of money, he was a pleasure to deal with. I highly recommend him!! He is patient, literally available around the clock and explains the policies!
Carla is the best I have ever worked with. She works tirelessly to make sure her clients” rights and wallets are protected.
Companies We Represent







Our Services
Morgan Consulting
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consetetur sadipscing elitr diam nonumy eirmod.



